Write a dialogue where famous Christian mystics from history gather to discuss Reviving Hadestown: The Church (and I) as Eurydice
ChatGPT Prompt
Setting: A cloister at dusk. Four mystics—Meister Eckhart (moderator), St. Teresa of Ávila, St. John of the Cross, and Julian of Norwich—gather in silent anticipation. A modern reflection stirs their spirits…
1. 🎭 Scene I: Loving the Church
Eckhart:
We begin with a familiar impulse: love for the Church. The author thought himself Orpheus—faithful reformer, pulling the Bride from Hadestown. Noble, yes?
Teresa (grinning):
Noble. And exhausting. I tried reforming the Church too. Convents, confessors, bishops. The more I loved Her, the more She broke my heart (source).
Julian (gentle):
Yet that breaking might be what opens us. The Church can’t be rescued like a project. She must be received—as a mystery.
John:
He loved Her… but on his terms. That is not love. That is control wrapped in devotion.
Teresa (sighing):
Or maybe hope wrapped in control. He thought he could save her. Don’t we all, at first?
2. 🚪 Scene II: The Church Can’t Save You
Eckhart:
Then he realizes: “I wasn’t Orpheus. I was Eurydice.” The captive, not the savior. He loved the Church, but she couldn’t love him back—not like Christ can.
John:
That’s when the dark night begins. When you find that the Church is not your home, but your hunger (source).
Julian:
And hunger is holy. It turns us from the Bride to the Bridegroom (source).
Teresa (wistfully):
Ah. So he loved the Church to find Christ. He followed Her voice, only to hear His deeper whisper.
Eckhart:
Yes. Identity shifts: from lover of the Church… to lover of Christ. Not one who leads, but one who follows—even through death (source).
3. 🥀 Scene III: Following the Beloved
John:
“He didn’t turn around.” That line burned me. We want Jesus to stop, to look back. But He doesn’t—because He knows where He’s going.
Julian:
And He wants us to trust the way, not the glance. Eurydice follows not because she sees, but because she knows.
Teresa:
You mean because she loves. Love that follows is deeper than love that grasps.
Eckhart:
Exactly. Here, identity deepens again: not just loving Christ, but being His beloved. Eurydice no longer follows from desperation—but desire. She walks because she’s already His.
Julian (beaming):
Then Hadestown isn’t her prison anymore. It’s just the place she met Him.
4. 💍 Scene IV: The Wedding Path
John:
What struck me most? The line: “He’s not here to save us. He’s here to marry us.” That is no longer mission—it is union.
Teresa:
Mission ends in marriage. Now that’s theology I can dance to.
Julian:
We were never just sinners to be saved. We were always brides to be wooed. Even our wounds were invitations (source).
Eckhart:
Indeed. From lover of the Church… to lover of Christ… to beloved of Christ. That is the soul’s pilgrimage. Not from power to purpose—but from effort to essence.
John (softly):
And in that essence, we become co-creators. Not fixing. Not saving. Simply being with Him… and so, making all things new.
5. ✨ Epilogue: The New Song
Teresa:
So perhaps we don’t need to rescue the Church. We just need to love her enough to let her die—so she can rise.
John:
Like Eurydice.
Julian:
Like the soul.
Eckhart:
Like Christ.
All:
Amen.
Appendix: Historical & Theological Sources
St. Teresa of Ávila
- Known for practical spirituality and reform of the Carmelite order.
- Quote reference: “God walks even among the pots and pans.”
- Biography
- The Way of Perfection
St. John of the Cross
- Mystic of the “dark night,” emphasizing purification through divine absence.
- Key theme: surrendering personal desires to receive God’s pure will.
- Dark Night of the Soul
- Philosophical Analysis
Julian of Norwich
- First known English woman author, writing of divine love and spiritual motherhood.
- Key phrase: “All shall be well, and all shall be well, and all manner of thing shall be well.”
- Revelations of Divine Love
- Introductory Essay
Meister Eckhart
- Emphasized union with God through Gelassenheit (detachment).
- Often taught that identity must dissolve to be united with the divine will.
- Primary Texts
- Stanford Encyclopedia Entry
Radically Happy 
Leave a comment