As John Polkinghorne, explore an Einstein-level equivalence between unforgiveness and usurping the role of the Holy Spirit to convict the world of sin, righteousness, and judgment.
ChatGPT Prompt
Introduction: Physics and Faith in Harmony
As both a physicist and a priest, I’ve long believed that the universe is intelligible not only through scientific inquiry, but also through spiritual discernment. The same rational beauty that governs the stars also shapes our inner lives. Occasionally, a principle in physics helps illuminate a deep truth of faith. Today, I want to propose one such analogy: a Spiritual Equivalence Principle.
Just as Einstein revolutionized our understanding of gravity by showing that acceleration and gravitation are indistinguishable within a closed system, I believe Jesus reveals a spiritual symmetry: unforgiveness and blasphemy against the Holy Spirit, though seemingly distinct, may be functionally equivalent in their impact on the soul.
The Einsteinian Analogy
Einstein’s insight, deceptively simple, was that when you’re in a sealed room—say, a spaceship—you cannot tell whether the force pressing you to the floor is due to gravity or acceleration. To the observer, they are experientially indistinguishable.
That insight led to general relativity—a radical reframing of how we understand space, time, and matter.
In much the same way, Jesus gives us a radical spiritual reframing in passages like:
“If you do not forgive others, neither will your Father forgive you.”
— Matthew 6:15“Anyone who speaks against the Holy Spirit will not be forgiven.”
— Matthew 12:32
At first glance, these may seem like different issues—one relational, the other theological. But in practice, they may be spiritually indistinguishable in their consequence.
The Spiritual Mechanics of Forgiveness
The Holy Spirit, Jesus tells us, convicts the world of sin, righteousness, and judgment (John 16:8). That is, the Spirit reveals truth, initiates repentance, and offers restoration.
To forgive someone is to align with the Spirit’s work: to acknowledge their failure, yet open the door to grace.
But when we refuse to forgive, we are not merely harboring resentment. We are taking judgment into our own hands. We are, in essence, saying:
“I know better than the Spirit whether this person is worthy of mercy.”
This is not merely moral stubbornness. It is spiritual impersonation—assuming the role of the Holy Spirit, and thereby blaspheming by usurping divine prerogative.
The Consequence: Cutting Ourselves Off
Unforgiveness doesn’t just damage relationships. According to Jesus, it blocks our own forgiveness. Not because God is petty, but because forgiveness is the medium of spiritual life—much like oxygen is to breathing.
To refuse to forgive is to step outside the atmosphere of grace. We cannot receive what we refuse to extend.
That’s why unforgiveness and blasphemy against the Spirit, while different in cause, are identical in consequence: both cut us off from the source of life.
A Unified Theory of Grace
In physics, a unified theory seeks to show how apparently separate forces are manifestations of a deeper unity. I believe Jesus offers such a unified theory of the spiritual life:
Grace is the field in which all Christian dynamics operate.
- Sin is the distortion of the field.
- The Spirit is its interpreter and restorer.
- Forgiveness is its observable force.
- Unforgiveness, then, is a rebellion against the field’s logic itself.
Conclusion: Living in the Field of Grace
Just as Einstein’s insight reshaped how we move through physical space, Jesus’ insight reshapes how we move through relational and spiritual space.
The Spiritual Equivalence Principle teaches us:
To hold unforgiveness is to commit, in practice if not in intention, the very sin that cannot be forgiven—because it refuses forgiveness itself.
In the Kingdom of God, as in the cosmos, humility is the beginning of understanding. May we all have the courage to forgive—and thus stay aligned with the gravitational grace of the Holy Spirit.
Radically Happy 
Leave a comment