Write a historically plausible skit where Dietrich Bonhoeffer chooses public martyrdom over condoning violence, triggered by a poster for a 1940 national day of prayer on Hitler’s birthday. Frame the dilemma using his fiancée Maria as a pacifist and Hans his brother-in-low as a pragmatist. Use John Woo-inspired visuals, and ask Mitch Teemley to improve the characters and plot.
ChatGPT Prompt (condensed)
Prologue
Narrator:
“In 1939, Dietrich Bonhoeffer, theologian and pastor, stood at the crossroads of faith and resistance. Nazi Germany demanded loyalty to the Führer, plunging the nation into darkness. Bonhoeffer, a man of deep conviction, joined a secret resistance within the Abwehr, passing names of Jewish refugees to his brother-in-law Hans von Dohnányi.
But questions haunted him. Was quiet resistance enough? Could his faith reconcile inaction—or violence?
This story imagines a moment when Bonhoeffer, caught between faith, action, and despair, made a choice to confront evil, not with weapons, but with truth. The goal is not to second-guess his choices, but honor his real-life legacy by grappling with the questions he faced: What does it mean to serve God in the face of tyranny? And what is the cost of standing for truth?”
Scene 1: Wrestling with Enough
Setting: A modest sitting room. Dietrich sits at a table, surrounded by Hans von Dohnányi, Maria von Wedemeyer, and Wilhelm Canaris. A dossier lies open in the center, its pages filled with intelligence and plans. The lighting is dim and intimate, emphasizing the tension between the characters.
Hans:
(Slamming his hand on the table)
“This is the best chance we’ve had in months. We know Hitler’s schedule, his movements—if we act now, we can stop him before he plunges us into even greater madness!”
Maria:
(Speaking softly, her knitting in her lap)
“And what happens when they retaliate, Hans? How many more innocents will die because of what you’ve done?”
Canaris:
(Leaning back, measured)
“They’re already dying, Maria. Every day, more people are sent to camps, more families torn apart. We cannot afford to wait any longer.”
Dietrich:
(Looking at the dossier, his voice calm but strained)
“You speak as if the answer is clear. But how can I reconcile this with my faith? How can I ask God to bless violence, even against such evil?”
Hans:
(Snarling)
“Your faith is a privilege, Dietrich, not a strategy. While you pray, people are being loaded onto trains. Do you think God is silent because He agrees with your hesitation?”
Maria:
(Sharply)
“Hesitation? You think Dietrich hesitates out of fear? His resistance is rooted in conviction, Hans. What is yours rooted in?”
Hans:
(Turning to Maria)
“It’s rooted in reality! I have to make choices every day that weigh lives against lives. And so does he.”
Canaris:
(Cutting in)
“The question isn’t what’s right, Dietrich. It’s what’s necessary.”
(A tense silence falls over the room. Dietrich looks between them, then rises slowly, the weight of their words visibly pressing on him.)
Dietrich:
(Quietly, but firmly)
“Necessary? Necessary for whom? For us, or for the God we claim to serve?”
(He moves toward the door, taking his coat.)
Maria:
(Softly, looking up from her knitting)
“Where are you going?”
Dietrich:
“To pray. If there is a way forward, it must come from Him.”
(He exits. Maria’s hands tremble as she returns to her knitting. Hans slumps back in his chair, staring blankly at the dossier.)
Scene 2: The Night Prayer
Setting: A quiet street under a pale moon. Dietrich walks alone, the sound of distant sirens and trains faintly audible. He stops beneath a lamppost, kneeling on the cobblestones.
Dietrich:
(Praying aloud)
“Lord, I kneel before You in darkness, torn between paths that all feel wrong. Hans calls for action. Maria for peace. Canaris for necessity. But what do You call me to do? Show me the way, Father. Give me the strength to walk it, even if it breaks me.”
(A faint flutter catches his attention. He looks up to see a poster stuck to the lamppost: “National Day of Prayer: Honor Our Führer and Our Nation.” Beneath it, a swastika and the date: April 20th.)
(Dietrich stares at the poster, his expression hardening.)
Dietrich:
(Softly, to himself)
“A prayer… for Hitler?”
(He steps back, shaking his head. As he turns, he notices a small wooden cross left on a nearby chapel wall. The moonlight casts its shadow across the cobblestones, merging with his own shadow.)
Dietrich:
(Approaching the crucifix, trembling)
“Not silence. Not violence. But a cross. Is this what You ask of me, Lord? To bear the weight of truth, even unto death?”
(He kneels beneath the shadow of the cross, his voice breaking.)
Dietrich:
“Let Thy will be done.”
(The light dims as the faint sound of a hymn—A Mighty Fortress Is Our God—rises softly in the background.)
Scene 3: The Plan
Setting: Back in the sitting room. Hans and Maria sit in tense silence as Dietrich enters, his face calm but resolute.
Hans:
(Looking up)
“Well? Did God speak to you?”
Dietrich:
(Quietly)
“Yes. There is a way forward. I will lead the National Day of Prayer.”
Maria:
(Startled)
“What? Dietrich, no!”
Hans:
(Staring at him)
“They’ll arrest you before you finish your first sentence.”
Dietrich:
“Perhaps. But the truth must be spoken. I will pray—for Hitler, yes, but also for his repentance. For Germany to awaken before it’s too late.”
Maria:
(Standing, her voice trembling)
“And what about us, Dietrich? What about me?”
Dietrich:
(Taking her hands gently)
“I will carry you with me, always. But I must carry the cross God has given me.”
Scene 4: The Prayer Service
Setting: A large church with Nazi banners. Dietrich steps to the pulpit as Gestapo officers Klaus and Franz sit watching.
Dietrich:
(Speaking solemnly)
“We gather today to pray for our leader, Adolf Hitler, and for our beloved Germany…”
(The congregation murmurs in approval.)
Dietrich:
(Pausing, his tone shifting)
“But today, I cannot pray for strength without justice. Nor can I pray for unity without compassion. For a leader who sheds innocent blood cannot stand before God unjudged.”
(The congregation stirs uneasily. Klaus and Franz whisper, then rise.)
Dietrich:
(Voice rising)
“Therefore I pray for Hitler’s repentance. For the forgiveness of our nation’s sins—idolatry, bloodshed, and the worship of power over truth. May we turn back to God before it’s too late!”
(The officers seize Dietrich as the congregation gasps.)
Dietrich:
(Looking out at the crowd)
“Faith cannot be silenced. Truth cannot be chained.”
Scene 5: Imprisonment and Execution
Setting: A dim prison cell. Dietrich sits at a table, writing his final words.
Dietrich (Voiceover):
“Lord, I offer my life into Your hands. If my words have stirred even one heart, if they have brought even one person closer to You, then my death is not in vain. Let Your light shine, even in the darkest places.”
(Lights dim as he is led to the gallows. His final words echo as the scene fades to black.)
Dietrich:
“This is the end. For me, the beginning of life.”
Epilogue
Narrator:
“In our reality, Dietrich Bonhoeffer was arrested in 1943 for his activities against the regime. After the failed July 20, 1944, assassination attempt on Adolf Hitler by people he knew, a crackdown on resistance members ensued. On April 9, 1945, Bonhoeffer was executed at Flossenbürg concentration camp, just weeks before the end of the war.
But Bonhoeffer’s story did not end there. His writings, including The Cost of Discipleship and Letters and Papers from Prison, have inspired generations to confront injustice with courage and faith.
Bonhoeffer reminds us that faith calls us not to complacency, but to conviction—and that the cross we carry may become a light for others in the darkness.”
(The stage fades to black as a soft hymn rises.)
Radically Happy 
Leave a comment